George W. Bush:
Signed
the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act
of 2001, which lowered the top tax bracket by 4.6%
and the next three brackets by 3% each, resulting in the top 1% of
income earners receiving 80% of the tax break, widening the
gap between rich and poor.
Pushed through a
series of tax cuts, including the bonus depreciation tax cut,
the phase-out of the federal estate tax, elimination of the capital
gains tax, tax breaks for corporations and many others. Almost none
of these cuts have been paid for by corresponding reductions in federal
spending and the administration has opposed efforts to limit tax cuts
with "pay-as-you-go" controls.
Note: Numerous analyses have shown that these tax
cuts and many others have gone primarily to the top one percent of households
(whose incomes average nearly $1.2 million annually) which received
an average tax cut of $40,990 in 200440 times the average tax
break for those in the middle fifth of the income distribution. The
lowest 20 percent of income earners received only $230, on average.
Turned a $5.6 trillion surplus into
a deficit. The estimated deficit for the current fiscal year
is about $422 billion. By 2010, the total federal deficit due is projected
to be $5.5 trillion! The resulting decline in federal revenues has already
meant that serious funding reductions are being made in a wide array
of social programsharming many women and children.
Squandered the surplus as well as
the revenue needed to strengthen Social Security for the long term.
This problem compounds with the increasing life expectancy and the shrinking
ratio between workers and retirees. Under current law, Social Security
will lose its ability to pay 100% of promised benefits by the year 2042.
Eliminated the Equal Pay Matters
Initiative, a Department of Labor (DOL) program to improve
enforcement of laws on ending sex and race pay discrimination, reduce
occupational sex segregation and promote pension equity and then removed
all information materials from the agency's web site. The gender wage gap is
not closing, but widening, due to a drop in women's earnings. The ratio
of female-to-male earnings for full-time, year-round workers was 76
cents for every dollar in 2003, down from 77 cents in 2002.
Bush's DOL adopted
new regulations (despite attempts in Congress to block them) that would deny about 3.7 million women overtime payan
important source of income for low- and middle-income workers.
The Bush DOL removed women's employment
fact sheets such as "Women's Earnings as Percent of Men's 1979-1997"
from government web sites, replacing them with pieces such as
"Hot Jobs for the 21st Century.
The Bush DOL failed to investigate
reported violations of equal pay laws, hampering appropriate
enforcement actions.
Bush's Department of Justice dropped
cases challenging sex discrimination in employment and weakened
laws against job discrimination.
Bush's Equal Employment Opportunities
Commission issued new guidelines that will make it harder to identify
whether race and sex discrimination is being practiced in federal agencies.
The term "under-represented" which identifies women and minorities
(federal agencies are still predominantly white and male), will no longer
be used and the collection of statistics about workforce demographics is
discouraged.
The Bush DOL withdrew a Clinton administration
regulation to allow for employee paid leave for the birth or
adoption of a child, under state Unemployment Compensation programs.
The Bush budget proposed cuts to
the Childcare and Development Block Granta program which
helps low-income families pay for child care. The program also provides
funds to improve the quality of child care. The proposed cuts would
remove up to 300,000 children from the program by 2009.
The proposed 2005 Bush budget fails
to renew the Modest Savers Credit, a tax credit to low- and
moderate-income individuals and families who contribute to a retirement
account.
Bush proposed replacing various types of employment-based
retirement plans with "Employer Retirement Savings Accounts." Current
non-discrimination rules which require that a portion of a company's
retirement contributions should be for low and moderate-income workers
would be weakened. In effect, protections for low-income workers would
be severely weakened.
The Bush administration's proposed
welfare policy would require poor women to work 40 hours a week, while
providing dramatically inadequate funds for child care during the
extra work hours and continuing to restrict poor women's
access to education and vocational training.
Bush diverted $2 billion of welfare
funding to marriage promotion programs, supposedly as a cure
to poverty. This risks women's safetyat least a third of welfare
recipients are or have been domestic abuse victims.
Bush promoted economic policies which
have failed to raise family incomes. More than one in four
working families earn wages so low that they have difficulty surviving
financially. One in five jobs in the U.S. are in an occupation that
pays less than a poverty-level wage for a family of four.
Bush opposes the Employee Free Choice Act, which allows workers to join a union free from employer intimidation, harassment and threats. In fact, since taking office, Bush has taken away the collective bargaining rights of nearly a quarter million government workers.
John Kerry:
Voted to enhance the Fair Labor Standards
Act of 1938 to better enforce legislation prohibiting wage discrimination
on the basis of gender.
Supported 1998 Higher Education Act
Amendments to allow states to accept education for work requirements
to receive welfare, allowing poor parents to acquire training while on
welfare.
Voted against the Economic Growth
and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001, which resulted in
the top 1% of income earners receiving 80% of the tax break.
As ranking member of the Senate Small Business
Committee, led Congressional efforts to maintain and improve
the Women's Business Center Programwhich provides five-year
grants of up to $150,000 a year to private-sector organizations to establish
small business training centers for women.
Co-sponsored the Employee Free Choice
Act, which would ensure that when a majority of employees in
a workplace decides to form a union, they can do so free from employer
intimidation, harassment and other obstacles used to block their efforts.
Ralph Nader:
As a lifelong consumer advocate, Nader
has lobbied for tax and insurance reforms that benefit the people, while
fighting against "corporate welfare." The organizations he
helped found have empowered people to demand consumer protections.
According to the AFL-CIO, he engaged in anti-union practices
such as firing organizers and filing intimidation suits against his
employees at Multinational Monitor and Public Citizen, stating: "I don't
think there is a role for unions in small nonprofit 'cause' organizations
any more than ... within a monastery or within a union."
|